Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBartol, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involved a promissory note executed during the Civil War era. The central dispute was whether the note was payable in Confederate currency or in lawful money of the United States. The Court of Appeals of Maryland, in a split decision, affirmed the judgment below. The majority (Bartol, C.J., Grason and Alvey, JJ.) held that by the construction of the note itself, the amount secured was payable in current bankable funds at the time and place for performance of the contract. The majority further concluded that extrinsic proof did not vary the meaning of the contract, even if such proof could properly be considered for that purpose. The dissent (Brent, Maulsby and Robinson, JJ.) would have held that the note, when construed in light of the facts and circumstances disclosed by the evidence, was payable in Confederate currency, and that the appellee was therefore entitled to recover
Questions presented
Whether the note, by its terms, was payable in current bankable funds or in Confederate currency.
Whether extrinsic proof could be considered to vary the meaning of the contract.
Bartol, C. J., and Grason and Alvey, J., concurred in the opinion that the judgment ought to be affirmed on the ground that by the construction of the note, the amount secured thereby was payable in current bankable funds at the time and place for the pérformance of the contract; and because there is nothing disclosed by the extrinsic proof, even if the same could properly be considered for that purpose, which varies the meaning of the contract itself. Brent, Maulsby and Robinson, J., dissented; being of opinion that the note, according to its terms, when construed in the light of the facts and circumstances disclosed by the evidence, was payable in Confederate currency, and that the appellee is therefore entitled to recover only an equivalent value in the lawful money of the United States, in accordance with the decision of the Supreme Court in Thorrington vs. Smith, 8 Wallace, 1