Maryland case law › Thomas's Lessee v. Hamilton
Thomas's Lessee v. Hamilton
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Reversed✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief note, taken from the notebook of Samuel Chase, records the 1752 Maryland case of Thomas's Lessee v. Hamilton (also referred to as Lee v. Hamilton), a dispute over title to Talbot's Manor. The principal question was whether Talbot's Manor, which had been granted to George Talbot, was forfeited to the Proprietary (the Lord Proprietor of Maryland) as a consequence of Talbot's conviction in Virginia for stabbing Christopher Rousby in Maryland. The Provincial Court held the conviction to be void, which would have preserved Talbot's title and, by extension, the title of those claiming under him. On appeal, the judgment of the Provincial Court was reversed. The note does not set forth the reasoning of the appellate court, the specific legal grounds for reversal, or any detailed facts beyond the grant, the conviction, and the procedural outcome. Because the text is merely a short hist
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether Talbot's Manor, granted to George Talbot, was forfeited to the Proprietary on conviction, in Virginia, of stabbing Christopher Rousby in Maryland.
The following note of this case is taken from the note» book of Samuel Chase, Esquire, one of the Judges of the Supreme Court of the United States; “ The dispute in the case of Lee v* Hamilton was about “ Talbot's Manor; and the principal question was, whether 44 Talbot's Manor, granted to George Talbot, was not for» u feited to the Proprietary, on conviction, in Virginia, of M stabbing Christopher Rousby in Maryland. The Pro» 4‘ vincial Court held the conviction to be void. The judg a ment was reversed^