Maryland case law › Thomas v. Malster

Thomas v. Malster

14 Md. 382 (1859) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on appeal from a judgment of the court below. The plaintiff had previously obtained a rule against the defendants, requiring them to show cause why the judgment should not be made complete and taken as a judgment nunc pro tunc. The court below discharged that rule. The same subject-matter was subsequently presented again in a different form, and the court below ruled against the plaintiff. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Tuck, J.) affirmed solely on the ground that the matter had already been decided by a court of competent jurisdiction when it discharged the earlier rule, and that such a decision is final as between the parties. The Court expressly declined to express any opinion on the correctness of the earlier decision, reasoning that whether right or wrong, the parties are concluded by it, and the only remedy for a party aggrieved is an ap
Questions presented
  • Whether the court below erred in ruling against the plaintiff on the subject-matter after having previously discharged the rule to show cause why the judgment should not be made complete and taken as a judgment nunc pro tunc.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J,, delivered the opinion of this court. In expressing our concurrence with the ruling of the court below, we do so on the single ground that the subject-matter, in a different form, was passed upon by the court on discharging the rule laid at the instance of the plaintiff on the defendants, to show cause why the judgment should not be made complete, and taken as a judgment, “nunc pro tunc” it being well settled that when a matter has been once decided by a court of competent jurisdiction, it is final as between the par 388 ties. We express no opinion on the correctness of that decision, for whether right or wrong, the parties are concluded, the remedy being by an appeal if the party conceived himself aggrieved. Beall vs. Brown's Adm'r, 12 Md. Rep., 550.

(Decided July 29th, 1859.) Judgment affirmed.