Maryland case law › Tillard's Lessee v. Fisher
Tillard's Lessee v. Fisher
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief report concerns a land dispute in which the defendant had been in possession by enclosures for more than twenty years. The court set aside an award because an error of law appeared on its face: the arbitrator had failed to apply the Statute of limitations, which the court found should attach where the defendant had been in possession by enclosures for more than twenty years. The court doubted its power to reinstate the cause for trial, but did so with the consent of the defendant's counsel. At May term, 1794, the court determined that the cause could not be reinstated. The parties were then obliged to docket the suit anew, file a new declaration, and agreed to admit the old proceedings as part of the new suit. The report does not set forth the underlying facts of the land dispute, the identity of the parties beyond the case name, or the specific procedural steps that led to th
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the award should be set aside for an error of law apparent upon its face, specifically whether the Statute of limitations attaches where the defendant had been in possession by enclosures for more than twenty years.
- Whether the court had the power to reinstate the cause for trial after setting aside the award.
The Court set aside the award, there being an error in law apparent upon the face of the award, as to the Statute of limitations not attaching where the defendant had been in possession by enclosures for more than twenty years. The court doubted their power to reinstate the cause for trial. It was done, however, with the consent of the defendant’s counsel. At May term, 1794, the court determined that the cause could not be reinstated, and the parties were obliged to docket the suit, file a new declaration, and agreed to admit the old proceedings as a part of the new suit.