Maryland case law › Tyson v. Tyson

Tyson v. Tyson

37 Md. 567 (1873) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherBowie, J. (dissenting); Stewart, J. (dissenting)✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arises from a caveat filed in the Orphans' Court of Baltimore City against two codicils (dated April 12, 1860, and January 15, 1861) to the will of Isaac Tyson, Jr. The caveators (appellants) alleged that the codicils were procured by fraud, misrepresentation, and undue influence exerted by the testator's sons and executors, James and Jesse Tyson, who were also the principal beneficiaries of the changes. The Orphans' Court sent issues to the Superior Court of Baltimore for a jury trial. At trial, the court granted the caveatees' prayers, which in effect were demurrers to the evidence, instructing the jury that there was no legally sufficient evidence to support the caveators' issues, and the jury returned a verdict for the defendants. The caveators appealed. The opinion below is a dissenting opinion by Judge Bowie, joined by Judge Stewart, arguing that the trial court erred in
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in granting the caveatees' prayers, which withdrew the case from the jury by declaring there was no legally sufficient evidence to support the caveators' issues of fraud and undue influence.
  • Whether the evidence offered by the caveators was legally sufficient to require submission to the jury on the issues of fraud and undue influence in the procurement of the codicils.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bowie, J., delivered the following dissenting opinion : The last will and codicils of Isaac Tyson, Jr., were probated in common form, in the Orphans’ Court of Baltimore City, on the 29th of November, 1861, by his executors, James and Jesse Tyson, and the petition of the appellants, caveating the codicils of the 12th of April, 1860, and the 15th of January, 1861,'was filed the 5th June, 1871. On the 28th of August, 1871, plenary proceedings having been instituted by the appellants, the Orphans’ Court directed several issues to be sent for trial, to the Superior Court of Baltimore. These issues presented substantially the questions whether the papers dated the 12th of April, 1860, and 15th January, 1861, respectively, purporting to be codi 595 oils to the last will and testament of the deceased testator, or either of them, was procured by fraud, misrepresentation, undue influence or other devices which he was then too weak to resist, etc. At the trial in the Superior Court, a verdict was found for the defendants, alter a series of prayers submitted respectively by the caveators, and caveatees ; those of the former being refused, and those of the latter granted ; to which action of the Court below the appellants excepted and prayed an appeal. The instructions granted at the instance of the appellees, among other propositions declared, that there was no evidence in the cause, that the testator executed the paper writings of the 12th of April, 1860, and of the 15th of January, 1861, purporting to be codicils to his last will and testament, under the influence of suggestions, importunities, or misrepresentations, when his mind from its enfeebled state, was unable to resist the same, and that the jury must find for the defendants on the second and fifth issues.

That there was no evidence in the cause, that the said paper writings were procured by undue influence, fraudulent devices, importunities, misrepresentations and deceits, practised upon the testator, which under the circumstances, did not leave him free in the disposition of his estate, and that the jury must find for the defendants on the third and sixth issues. Among the propositions submitted by the appellants and rejected by the Court were the following: 1. If the 'jury should find from the evidence, that in executing the codicil of the 15th January, 1861, the testator was influenced by an estimate of his estate, such as no rational mind would have made in view of the actual value of his estate, as shown by the evidence, the jury might find that he did not at the date of said codicil possess testamentary capacity, and so finding, their verdict should be for the caveators on the fourth issue, not 596 withstanding they might find that the testator, as to all other matters, was sane and rational and capable of making a valid deed or contract.. And in ascertaining whether said alleged codicil was executed under the influence of such an estimate, the jury might consider the codicil'itself, the original will and first codicil, and the proof offered as to the actual amount and vadue of the estate of the testator, and all the other facts and circumstances of the case. 2.

If the jury believed the alleged codicil of the 15th of January 1861, was executed by the testator under the influence of an estimate of his estate, and at that time,, and before, by reason of age and infirmities was unable to manage his property without the assistance of his executors, who in consequence of his debility, had been entrusted with the management of his estate, so as to enable them to know its real amount and value; and the testator so confided in them, that at the time of executing the said codicil, they possessed influence over him, and that the estimate of his estate, under the influence of which he executed said codicil, was false and inconsistent with its actual value, and the said executors derived advantage from the execution of the said codicil, and were aware that the testator in making the codicil was influenced by such false estimate, then, unless the jury believed the said executors informed the testator, the said estimate was erroneous, the jury might find the said codicil was obtained by fraud, notwithstanding they might believe the testator was of sound mind and capable of making a valid deed or contract-. And in ascertaining whether the testator was influenced to make said codicil by a false estimate of the value of his estate, the'jury might consider the original will and the first and second codicils, in connection with the other testimony in the case. . 3. If the jury believed that the testator was induced to make the codicil of the 12th of April, 1860, by belief in 597 the truth of the reports as to the conduct of the mother of the caveators, and such reports were calculated to prejudice his mind against her, and the defendants by their influence over him induced him to believe said reports, and withheld all social intercourse with her, pretending to believe said reports as long as the testator lived, and after his death, renewed their intercourse, declaring they had not believed them, the jury might find the codicil of the 12th of April, 1860, was obtained by fraud and undue influence, etc. 5. That there was evidence on the face of the codicil of January 15th, 1861, from which the jury might find, that the executors at the time of its execution, were aware the testator made the same on the basis of an estimate of his estate, and that the said estimate, and the effect which it would have upon the disposition of the estate oí' the testator, by the codicil, was also known to the executors at the time of its execution.

The last prayer was rejected “as unnecessary to be passed upon by the Court, seeing that the Court has already determined by the granting of the caveatees’ prayers, that there is no sufficient evidence upon which they can find for the plaintiffs — the caveators. A synopsis of the evidence offered by the caveators to support the issues, on their part, is necessary to enable us to judge of the correctness of the propositions submitted in their prayers and of the propriety of the action of the Court, in rejecting them and granting the instructions given by it, in favor of the caveatees. The evidence embodied in the bills of exceptions consists of written documents, letters, and oral testimony, too voluminous to be repeated, but its substance will be condensed as far as practicable in illustration of these views. Evidence was offered by the caveators, tending to prove that the testator was a gentleman far advanced in age, as far back as 1856 or 1857, in very bad health, tremulous, and palsied ; in consequence 598 of which extreme ill health, his sons, Jesse and James, had taken hold of his business.

His estate at the date of his will, 7th January, 1860, was worth nearly $800,000. His family consisted of a wife, a daughter jind four sons, Jesse Tyson, Isaac Tyson, called Isaac the 3d, James W. Tyson and Richard W. Tyson. Isaac Tyson the 3d, was married and had two children living at the death of the testator. In a conversation in 1859, with a witness.'he said that he thought that such of his children as knew how to take care of their property, he would leave them their part free, but that the others he would leave in trust, and that nothing could induce him to make any other difference between his children ; that he did not think a parent had any right to make any other distribution than this between his children ; that, testator was the most affectionate of parents.

At this time, the habits of Isaac Tyson, the 3d, were bad. His father seemed to have more affection for him than for any other of his children. He knew his habits when he stated his views of his duty to his children, and the habits had at that time been for some years as bad as they could be. He spoke of his affection for Isaac’s children and seemed to be more interested in them on account of the father’s habits.

Isaac Tyson, the 3d, had .become deeply embarrassed from improvidence or other causes. His family and himself were supported by his father. His household establishment in Virginia was broken up; he was induced to go t,o sea, (according to the evidence of the caveators) by the influence of his mother and brothers, against the wishes and advice of his father, and his wife arid children boarded in Baltimore. In this state of affairs, the testator, shortly before the date of his will, (the 7th of January, I860,) called on his 599 counsel, and told him he wanted him to draw his will. “He brought to the witness, a will which had been drawn for the testator by Mr. Talbott, of the firm of Dobbin & Talbott.

He said be wanted-a shorter and less technical will, and witness accordingly drew a shorter paper in more familiar language. The testator’s counsel testified that the testator had frequently talked to him of' making a new will, but had done nothing towards carrying that purpose into effect, until he came to the office of the witness, bringing with him a draft of the will made by Mr. Talbott. He objected to the technical language of that will; and witness therefore expressed the same ideas in his own language. There was no alteration in the substance.

The will of the 7th January, 1800, modelled on one previously-drawn by Mr. Talbott was then executed. This will, after making provision for his wife, devised to his three sons, Richard, Jesse and James, as trustees, in trust for his daughter, Mrs. H. A. Morris, twenty-five thousand dollars. To his sons, Richard, Jesse and James, $25,000 each. After reciting that he had been engaged in partnership with his son Jesse in carrying on chrome works, and investing his executors with discretionary powers to continue the same, providing compensation to them for such services, he devised to the trustees in fee the residuum of his estate to be divided into five equal parts, and held in trust as follows: one-fifth in trust for Mrs. Hannah A." Morris, for her sole and separate use; one-fifth in trust for Richard W. Tyson; one-fifth in trust for Jesse Tyson; one-fifth in trust for James W. Tyson ; one-fifth in trust for his son Isaac Tyson, the 3d, for life, he to take and receipt for the income thereof only, but without power of anticipation or involuntary alienation; should he die without child, children or descendants, the said one-fifth to go to the brothers and sister of Isaac; should he leave 600 a child or children, the said fifth to go to said child or children, and should all of the children of said Isaac die without descendants, the said fifth to go to the brothers and sisters of the said Isaac, “per stirpes,” and not “per capitathe said fifth in whosoever hands it might be, to be subject to an annuity of $1,200, payable to the widow of said Isaac, during her widowhood.

The -will further directed that all sums, charged against his sons and daughter in his books, at his death, and all moneys for which he might be responsible on their accountat that time, should be charged against their respective legacies and portions of his estate, by his executors. About four months after the execution of the will,.without any ostensible reason or apparent change in the conduct or condition of the devisees, the codicil of the. 12th of April, I860, was executed. This codicil revoked so much of the will as relates to the payments therein directed to be made to his son Isaac Tyson the 3d, and his wife, in the event of his dying before her, and directs the trustees to pay Isaac only so much of the income as in their judgment may he proper in vieio of all the circumstances, and instead of $1,200 to Ms wife, if she survived him, to pay her only such part oCs they may think proper; the excess of the income to be. held in trust for the benefit of Isaac, aad the excess of the allowance to his wife to be held in trust for the benefit of the children of said Isaac. The Codicil of the 15th of January, 1861, was next executed.

It declares that its provisions in regard to his son Isaac Tyson the 3d, his wife and children, shall be substituted in lieu of the provisions made for them in his last will and testament,' which are thereby revoked and annulled. By this codicil the testator bequeathed $50,000 to his executors, etc., in trust, to be invested by them in their discretion,' in securities producing income, and held for the following purposes: 601 1st. In trust during the life of his son Isaac, to expend the income thereof, in their discretion as to time, manner and objects of expenditure, for the maintenance of said Isaac and his family, and the education of his children. 2dly. At the death of said Isaac, the sum of $50,000 shall be held by his executors in two sums of $40,000 and $10,000, respectively.

So much of the income of the sum of $40,000, as may he allowed for the purpose by the Orphans’ Court of Baltimore city, to he paid to the guardian of the children of said Isaac, living at the time of his death, for their education a,nd maintenance; the surplus to he invested for the benefit of the children. 3dly. At the death of his son Isaac the income of the sum $10,000 to he paid to his widow, so long as she remains sole, and on her death or marriage, the principal to be added to the fund of $40,000, for the benefit of the children. It was further provided, should Isaac survive his children, then on his death and that of his widow, the sums of $40,000 and $10,000 above devised, should become a part of the residuum of his estate, and divided as already provided, except that the residuum should be divided into four parts and not five, the codicil being intended to provide for his son Isaac, as aforesaid, “who under my original will was to receive a fifth part of the residuum.” The codicil concludes with this remarkable clause: “In the bequest here made by me, I have had regard to an estimate, according to my best judgment, of what my estate will probably authorize to be paid, having a due regard to other members of my family. But inasmuch as it may so happen that such a division would not accomplish my wishes in this connection, and' whereas my executors are fully informed of my will in this respect, I hereby authorize them to diminish at their pleasure, the above sum of $50,000 during the lifetime of Isaac the 3d, so as not to reduce it below $25,000; and the above mentioned sum of $40,000, after his death, so as hot to reduce 602 it below $20,000, and tbe said sum of $10,000, so as not to reduce it below the sum of $5,000.

It being understood that the sum of $50,000 includes as well the sum of $40,000, as said sum of $10,000.” The third and last codicil, dated the 9th of May, 1861, declares that, having by his will appointed certain duties to be performed by trustees, and being satisfied his will would be simplified by making the same persons executors and trustees, he directs that the executors named in his will, shall be also trustees, and invested with all the powers conferred on the trustees, his purpose being to concentrate-in his executors the powers and duties in his will and codicil divided between the executors and trustees. The counsel of the deceased, who drafted the will and codicils, testified that when he prepared the codicil of the 15th January, 1861, the habits of Isaac Tyson, the son, were referred to by the testator as a reason for making that codicil. The consequences to. ensue from making it were never a subject of discussion. They never talked about the efiect the codicil would have on the children of his son Isaac.

It was further in evidence on the part of the appellants that Isaac Tyson, the 3d, was sent to sea in the year 1859, by the conjoint advice and influence of Jesse and James Tyson and their brother, contrary to the 'wishes of their father, and that the wife and children of Isaac Tyson the 3d, came to Baltimore, and were established at a boardinghouse ; that James and Jesse wanted the wife to go to the country-seat of their father, and occupy the overseer’s house, whilst their father wished her to occupy the farmhouse. Soon after her arrival in Baltimore a misunderstanding arose between James and Jesse and their families, and the wife of Isaac the third, the mother of the appellants, in consequence of certain defamatory rumors uttered 603 against her, and a non-intercourso ensued, but the testator visited her privately, and desired her not to mention his visits to his sons or his wife. The testator continued affectionate in his manner toward the wife of Isaac, and expressed his solicitude for her husband and her children. During the residence of the wife of Isaac Tyson the 3d, at this boarding-house, her husband returned from sea, but did not visit her for sometime, and an attempt was made by one of the executors, and her husband, to take her children from her and carry them away.

During this estrangement between the sons and executors of the testator, and the wife of Isaac Tyson the 3d, the codicil of the 12th April, 1860, was executed, whereby the provisions-of the will giving annually to Isaac Tyson, the 3d, during his life, the whole amount of the profits accruing to him from his portion of the testator’s estate, and also to Fannie Tyson, wife of said Isaac, in the event of his death, twelve hundred dollars, as an annuity to be paid to her during her widowhood, was revoked, and the executors were directed to pay to Isaac Tyson the 3d, so much only of the income of his fifth part of the estate as in their judgment might be proper in view of all the circumstances, and in lieu of $1,200 to be paid to his wife, should she survive him, to pay to her, in their discretion only such part, if any thereof, as they might think proper. An experienced physician, who visited the testator, in the summer of 1861 professionally, as many as thirty times, deposed that the testator’s general health was very feeble; he seemed to be affected with softening of the posterior part of the brain, which in his opinion was of some years standing. It was the strongest case of the kind the witness had ever seen; he had a history of the case from Dr. Norris, and knew that it had been coming on for several years. 604 That one of the first symptoms of such a disease as the testator had, is often seen in its effect upon the mind of the patient,'in producing or confirming morbid feelings and impressions as to persons and things. The witness said he saw nothing in his conversations with the testator which would have induced him to suppose his mind was impaired in such a way as to render him incompetent to make a will'.

The effect of his disease on the nerves and muscles need not have affected his mental powers. “Being asked the hypothetical question, that if he had known at the time he saw him, that the testator was a very wealthy man, and that his estate was sufficient to-pay the sum of $50,000, without being seriously impaired, and that the testator’s estimate of its value was such as to make him apprehend that such a sum or a less one could not be paid from it to one of his children without endangering a due provision for the other four, would he have attested his will? The witness answered, no; he would have considered him crazy, and that he had not a reasonable knowledge and opinion as to his estate." The appellants gave in evidence the list of debts returned by the executors 22d October, 1862, showing sperate debts to the amount of $459,801.40 ; doubtful debts, $40,182.65. Among the debts in the schedule of the sperate, due by the children of the testator, were, Jesse Tyson........................ $13,092.84. Jas.

W. Tyson..................... 132,505.77. Jesse Tyson & Co................. 162,146.12. Among the debts reported doubtful was Isaac Tyson......................... $28,340.84. The caveators, assuming they had shown by sufficient evidence that the testator, being of sound mind and memory, and capable of disposing of his estate by last will, 605 had made a will in conformity with previous declarations of his intention, and natural love and affection, providing for an improvident son, and his family, then knowing all the infirmities of the prodigal, and anxiously protecting him, and his wife and children, by creating ,a trust in their behalf; that three months thereafter, whilst the son was at sea, without any provocation on his part, the dispositions of the will providing for the son and his wife, during their joint lives, and the widowhood of' the wife in case she survived, were revoked, and their allowance reduced to such sum as the caveatees in their discretion should allow; that the caveatees at this time were not on visiting terms with the mother of the caveators; that by the operation of the second codicil, made evidently with the privity of the caveatees, the testator under an apprehension that his estate, “having regard to the other members of his family,” would not warrant a more liberal provision, reduced the share of Isaac Tyson the 3d, and his children, from one-fifth of the residuum of his estate to $50,000, with an authority to the executors to reduce it to $25,000; the residuum of his estate being divided by the same instrument into four parts instead of five; and the portion of the caveatees thereby increased ; that this codicil was evidently made under a morbid misapprehension of his own circumstances, with the knowledge of the caveateés.

That the estate of the testator was worth nearly a million of dollars; and the caveatees were its principal debtors. That all the changes made in the original will, enured to their benefit and advantage, and the ostensible reasons for them were unreal or delusions. That the testator during this time was extremely aged, palsied and dependent in a great measure, physically as well as mentally, on the caveatees for the management of his affairs, contended that from these premises it necessarily resulted that the codicils of the 12th April, 1860, and the 15th of January, 1861, were the productions of a non 606 sane mind, or of a weak and morbid intellect, motilded by influences, and controlled by agents, it was too feeble to resist.' The prayers of the caveators presented the affirmative of these propositions, and those of the caveateesthe negative, with some particular exceptions; the general effect of the whole being as stated in the record that the Court determined by granting the caveatees’ prayers, that there was no sufficient evidence upon which the jury could find for the plaintiffs, the caveators. The effect of these prayers was to withdraw the facts from the consideration of the jury, and submit to the Court the question, whether, conceding all that had been offered in evidence on the part of the caveators to be true, and all inferences reasonably deducible from them, they were sufficient in law to support any of the issues in favor of the caveators.

In other words, the prayers were demurrers to the evidence, and subject to the same rules and limitations, and can only be proper where the demurrer to evidence would be. As to the latter, the following principles are established: “ If the plaintiff or defendant give in evidence matter of record or parol evidence on which a doubt in law arises, the other side may demur to the evidence; othemvise if there be a doubt whether the fact be well proved, for the jury may find it on their own knowledge. 2 Stephens N. P. Tit. Evid., 1792; Buller N. P., 312, (a;) Coke Litt., 72, (a.) “In Wright vs. Pindar, Aleyn. 18, it was resolved, ‘that he that demurs upon the evidence ought to confess the whole matter of fact to be true, and not refer that to the judgment of the Court; and if the matter of fact be uncertainly alleged, or that it be doubtful, whether it-be true or no, because offered to be proved only by presumptions and probabilities, and the other party will demur thereupon, he that alleges this matter cannot join in 607 demurrer with him, but ought to pray judgment of the Court, that he may not be admitted to his demurrer, unless he will confess the matter of fact to be true.” Stephens’ N. P., 1793. The books also agree that if parol evidence be offered, and the adverse party demur, he who offers the evidence may join in the demurrer if he will.

But the language of the old books is very indistinct upon the question whether the party offering ¡the parol evidence shall be obliged to join in the demurrer. Tidd’s Prac., 866; Stephens’ N. P. supra. On demurrer to circumstantial evidence the party offering the evidence is not obliged to join in demurrer, unless the party demurring will distinctly admit upon the record every fact and every conclusion which the evidence offered conduces to prove. Gibson vs. Hunter, 2 H. Black., 187; 6 Bro.

P. C., 255, cited by Stephens. “On the demurrer to evidence, the only question for the consideration of the Court is, whether the evidence given be such as ought to be left to the jury in support of the issues joined; and no objection can be made to the declaration or other pleadings in' that stage of the cause ; for the party ought to admit the whole effect of the evidence, and not merely the facts which compose it; so that, if it be only presumptive, he must distinctly admit every conclusion, which the jury might have drawn from it.” 2 Hen. Black., 187, cited in 2 Stephens’ N. P., 1793. The jealous regard for the maxim of the common law, “ad questioned fa, di respondeant jur atores,” shown by the preceding authorities, upon demurrers to evidence, is indirectly, if not so emphatically expressed, in the decisions of this Court, as to the circumstances under which they feel authorized to withdraw the facts from the consideration of the jury, and the concessions to be made by the party asking the Court to declare the law upon the facts given in evidence. 608 In Davis vs. Davis, 7 H. & J., 36, this Court declared : “ Wherever the testimony adduced hy a plaintiff, is so light and inconclusive, that no rational, well-constructed mind can infer from it the fact which it is offered to establish, it is the duty of the Court, when applied to for that purpose, to instruct the jury there'is no evidence before them to .warrant their finding the fact thus attempted to be proved.” In Cole vs. Hebb, 7 G. & J., 20 , this Court referring to the same subject, define their duty thus: “An issue is made up of one or many facts according to circumstances; and where the evidence does not establish all the facts, either directly or by rational deductions, as where there is a failure of evidence in respect of any. pne material, fact involved in the issue, in such case, the evidence is not legally sufficient to warrant the jury in finding the issue which it is offered to sustain, and it is the duty of the Court to instruct them accordingly.” . In the earlier case of McElderry vs. Flannagan, the following propositions, were announced: “The jury alone are competent to decide on facts of which contradictory evidence may be offered. ' Before "the Court can legally give an absolute instruction to the jury on the prayer of one of the parties, they must admit the truth of the testimony offered by the other, and that also offered by the first, which may operate in his opponent’s favor, and the existence of all material facts which a rational mind can deduce therefrom, even though contradicted in every particular by the testimony of him who seeks the instruction.

Upon no other principle can the cause be withdrawn from the consideration of the jury.” 1 H. & G., 308 . In Ferguson vs. Tucker, 2 H. & G., 183, the Court defines the power to instruct the jury in these very forcible terms: “The prerogative of the Court which authorizes them to withdraw from the jury, the consideration of the facts, is never exercised but in cases where the 609 evidence is so indefinite and unsatisfactory, that nothing but wild, irrational conjecture, and licentious speculation, could induce a jury to pronounce the verdict which is sought at their hands.” See also Gray vs. Cook, 12 G. & J , 236. The conditions on which Courts of law in this State,« exercise what is called their prerogative, to withdraw the facts from the consideration of the jury are, it would appear from the foregoing decisions, and many others that might be cited, the same that govern the Courts of England upon demurrers to evidence viz: Every fact, and every rational inference from the facts proved by the party offering the evidence, must be conceded to be true, without reference to the opposing testimony, and the evidence must be so light and inconclusive that nothing but licentious speculation could induce a jury to pronounce the verdict sought for. We have seen that in England, where the issue is to be supported by circumstantial evidence or presumptions, the party offering the evidence could not be compelled to join in the demurrer to evidence, • Because the demurrer would only lie where the facts were ascertained, or certain, or there was a fixed standard to be appealed to, to determine their sufficiency to establish the issue to be proved.

The Court would not undertake to draw inferences from facts. Erom the principles on which demurrers to evidence, or instructions to juries that the evidence is not sufficient, are founded, the fact or issue to be found, must be one of a certain defined character, the constituent elements of the proof of which, are established and defined by law. In the case of the Mayor and City Council of Baltimore vs. Williams, speaking of a prayer asking the Court to instruct the jury that if they believed certain facts, then the deed was void for fraud, this Court said, “This prayer has been resisted, upon the ground that there is 610 no evidence to support it. We are not now sitting as a Court of Equity, to decide whether the evidence or circumstances relied upon by the appellees can be sufficient to establish the allegation of fraud, and consequently we are not called upon to say whether there is proof ^enough for that purpose.

But the instruction asks a Court of law to submit a question of fraud to the jury; and although we might believe the evidence not strong enough to require the jury to find the fraud, yet if there is any evidence legally tending to prove it, such a prayer could not properly be rejected. 6 Md., 267 . In the leading case of Davis vs. Calvert, 5 G. & J., 269 , this Court referring to questions then before them, on issues and prayers very similar, held this language: “There is ho 'question before us relating to- the construction of the will. Nor is it a question before this Court, whether the evidence offered, if true, would be sufficient to sustain the issues on the part of the appellants. That is not a subject for consideration on this appeal All that we are called upon to do, and can legitimately do, is to decide upon the-competency of 'that evidence and the correctness-of the instructions given to the jury.” Adverting to the issue of fraud, and the testimony necessary to support it, they thus announce the law. “ Fraud vitiates every thing with which it is connected.

A will or testament obtained by fraud is void, and though fraud,is never to be presumed, yet it is not necessary to prove it by positive and direct testimony. But being usually wrapt up in mystery, if well concerted, it is generally by circumstances only, by inductions of particulars, some of them often apparently trivial, that it can be brought to light and defeated.. And in a question of fraud, any fact, no matter how slight, bearing at all on the point at issue, and not wholly irrelevant, may be admitted. But the circumstances when combined and considered by the jury, should be so strong as to satisfy them of 611 the existence of the fact, they are offered to establish.” * * * * “ In short no competent means of ascertaining the truth ought to be rejected; and all the surrounding facts of a transaction that can be established by competent evidence may be submitted to a jury who are the judges of their force and effect.

Applying these principles of law, and rules of evidence to the present case, the testimony offered at the trial on the part of the appellant and rejected by the Court, should have been suffered to go to the jury as evidence of facts relevant to, and tending to prove the issues.” The remarks above cited, as their context implies, were made upon the rejection of certain items of evidence in the progress of the trial, but if the law requires every circumstance tending to prove the issue, however slight to be submitted to the jury, does it authorize the whole evidence, when collected, to be withdrawn from their consideration, by an instruction, in the nature of a demurrer to evidence, declaring there is no evidence to support issues, (involving an infinite variety of facts ánd inferences) but the jury mud find for one or the other of the parties to the cause ? What difference in effect, upon the right of trial by jury, is there between rejecting the evidence in mass, after the testimony has been closed, •and rejecting it in detail, as the trial progresses? The several items of evidence, could only have been admitted upon the presumption they tended to prove some of the issues joined, and when collected, they could not be of less weight. Their admission presupposes their competency in law ; their sufficiency in fact, is a question exclusively for the jury.

Conceding that where an issue is made up of one, or many facts, according to circumstances, and the evidence does not establish all the facts, either directly or by rational deductions, as where there is a failure of evidence in respect of any one of the material facts involved in the 612 issue ; in such case, the evidence is not legally sufficient to warrant the jury in finding the issue which it is offered to sustain, and it is the duty of the Court to instruct them accordingly, yet where the issues are to he sustained by inferences from facts to he found by the jury, by circumstances chiefly, and inductions of particulars, it is clear we think, the facts can no more be withdrawn from the consideration of a 'jury, by a prayer or instruction, than by a demurrer to evidence, which it is shown by authorities, cannot be had in such circumstances. The power can only be exercised, without infringing on the province of the jury, where the measure and quantity of proof are established by law. Fraud and undue influence, are facts to be deduced from an infinite, undefined and undefinable variety of circumstances, which the Courts have refused to limit and prescribe, lest the ingenuity of evil, might assume other shapes to avoid the ban of the law, and escape its vigilance. The legal maxim “Dolus crescit in orbe” denotes its prevalence, and under whatever mask it may appear, its devices, however specious, are defeated.

This Court has recently in a series of much litigated cases on the subject of negligence laid down very clearly the principle which should control the Court, in my judgment, upon application, for instructions to the jury on the. legal effect of evidence. In the case of the Balto. & Ohio R. R. vs. The State use of Dougherty, 36 Md., 377 , the defendants endeavored to procure a prayer from the Court, instructing the jury what constituted negligence; the plaintiffs resisted the prayer on the ground that negligence was a fact for the consideration of the jury. Quoting from preceding decisions 21 Md., 275 , 24 Md., 53 , for the general proposition that what constitutes negligence was properly referred to the jury, they proceed: “Negligence, in a case like this, is not so much a question of law, as it is a question of fact, depending 613 for its determination upon a consideration of all the attending facts and circumstances in connection with the ordinary habits, conduct and motives of men. For the trial and determination of such a question a jury of experienced and intelligent men are peculiarly adapted.” “It is very true, negligence may in many cases become a question of law, to be determined by the Court, upon a given state of facts, either admitted or to be found by the jury.” “It is not, however, the duty oí' the Court te draw inferences and make deductions from evidence.

To do that falls within the well defined province of the jury, that Courts should ever be careful not to invade.” 29 Md., 420 . Fraud is not be considered as a single fact, but a conclusion to be drawn from all the circumstances of the case. Brogden vs. Walker, 2 H. & J., 285 , per Hanson Ch.; 6 H. & J., 442 ; Davis vs. Calvert, 3 G. & J., 269 , A plea of fraud, at law or in equity, never sets out the facts and circumstances which constitute the fraud. A demurrer could not be filed to such a plea, because there is no legal standard of what amounts to fraud.

For the same reason a demurrer to the evidence could not be sustained if there is a particle of testimony tending to prove it. It may not be unworthy of consideration that the issues in this case, were sent from the Orphans’ Court, under a statutory provision, intended to secure to suitors in that Court, the right of trial by jury in all cases in which issues of fact arise. The law never designed that the trial of facts should be transferred from the judges of the Orphans’ Court to the judges of the Courts oí' law, but to engraft upon the limited jurisdiction of the former, the trial by jury, that suitors might have the protection and benefit of that mode of ascertaining facts, and the Orphans’ Court be aided and assisted by the verdict. 614 It is true that on the trial of issues from the Orphans’ Court, the Circuit Courts are invested with the same powers, as in trials by jury originating in those Courts, yet the policy of the law would seem to dictate that a greater latitude should be allowed in issues involving the investigation of an infinite variety of facts, and incapable of being reduced to any single fact or ascertained state of facts, than in Courts of law. Stewart, J., delivered the following dissenting opinion: In addition to the reasons urged by my brother Bowie, in his dissenting opinion, in which I fully concur, there are other considerations, which weigh with me, looking to the relative duties of the Court and jury ; and the right of litigants, under our system of jurisprudence, to claim as matter of strict law the benefit of a trial by jury.

Suggestions as to the feelings and prejudices of juries, and the supposed greater freedom from such influences on the part of the Court, have no application to the determination of- the question. Its solution is solely dependent upon its constitutional and legal bearing. It is a maxim of the common law, that it is the province of the Court to determine questions of law in the "trial of causes, and of the jury to weigh and consider the import and bearing of facts. • Under our present Constitution, the parties litigant may refer both duties to the Court, but without their mutual consent, neither party can be deprived of his right of trial by jury. Some question had perplexed the Court as to the proper application of the relative duties of the Court and jury in criminal proceedings ; but that was set at rest by the constitutional provision that in criminal cases the jury were to be judges of the law as well as of the fact.

Under our testamentary system, issues may be framed, to be sent by the Orphans’ Court to a Court of law for trial by jury. 615 All these provisions show how carefully the rights of parties in regard to the respective position of Court and jury, were intended to be secured. It is manifest that where issues of fact are involved, and the right of a party to a trial by jury is insisted upon ; to justify the Court in the exercise of its prerogative, in withdrawing the consideration of the evidence from the jury, when it is competent and admissible, and tends to establish the issue it seeks ; the case should be so barren of proof as to leave no room for doubt or hesitation upon the subject; and if, upon such facts, a jury uninstructed should find a verdict, the Court would instantaneously set it aside. Without meaning to intimate what effect the testimony on the part of the caveators should have had upon the minds of .the jury, it certainly occurs to me that if it had been submitted to the jury, without instruction from the Court, and they had found for the caveators upon certain of the issues; it is not such a case, as would have authorized the Court upon that ground to have granted a new trial. In Davis vs. Barney, 2 G. & J., 382 , it is announced as the general rule, that where there is any legal admissible evidence, tending to prove the issue, the effect of that evidence is solely for the consideration of the jury.

The Court say, i£ there seems to be an impression that this Court has held the measure and quantity of proof to be a question of law, and the case of Davis vs. Davis, 7 H. & J., 36 , is relied upon in support of such doctrine.” ££ We, by no means mean to shake the authority of that case, but think it has been misunderstood.” <£ When there is no evidence applicable to the issue, or tending to prove any material fact, a total failure of evidence, the Court will direct the jury accordingly; and that we conceive to bo the doctrine of Davis vs. Davis.” l£ The expressions used are intended to be applicable to the facts of that case ; and so applied they are not opposed 616 to the principle here asserted, that if there be any evidence tending to the proof of the issue, however weak, it ought to be submitted to the consideration of the jury.” In Ferguson vs. Tucker, 2 H. &, G., 182, the same doctrine is reiterated; and it is emphatically stated that it by nojneans follows, even if the verdict would not be satisfactory to the minds of the Court, that they would feel themselves^authorized to withdraw from the jury the consideration of the facts — this prerogative of the Court is never exercised, but in cases where the evidence is so indefinite and unsatisfactory, that nothing but wild, irrational conjecture, or licentious speculation, could induce a jury to pronounce the verdict, which is sought at their hands ? In the case of Cole vs. Hebb, 1 G. & J., 20 , in which the antecedent cases are reviewed, and the doctrine of Davis vs. Barney, explained, the conclusion of the Court appears to have resulted in the announcement that evidence offered to a jury, has a two fold sufficiency — a sufficiency in law and á sufficiency in fact — its sufficiency in law is for the Court — its sufficiency in fact is a question exclusively for the jury — if, upon the ordinary principles of human judgment, a rational mind could draw from the proof the conclusions sought to be proved by it, then is its legal sufficiency established; and it must be submitted to the jury, who only are the judges of its sufficiency in point of fact. “ Whether the testimony be weak or strong ; conclusive or inconclusive ; sufficient or insufficient, to prove the facts or warrant the inferences, for the establishment of which it was offered, are questions for the exclusive cognizance of the jury.” As a fair and legitimate criterion of the relative duties of the Court and jury, in doubtful questions, as to the sufficiency of the proof in point of law; the Court further say, the testimony should never be withdrawn from the jury, whose province it is to decide upon its sufficiency in 617 fact, except in such case, where the Court would instantaneously set aside any verdict founded on its assumed sufficiency. The Court, under such circumstances would have to conclude that the jury themselves were totally deficient in a sane comprehension of facts, and the effect of proof. In the case of Green vs. Ford, 35 Md., 82 , recognizing the granting or witholding a new trial, as a fair and sensible test as to the nature of the proof and its sufficiency, the Court re-assert the principle, “that however unsatisfactory it may have appeared to the mind of the Court, yet if the jury could reasonably have reached a different conclusion, it should have heen considered by them ; the Court should not take the case from the consideration of the jury, unless the evidence is so trivial as to admit of no rational conclusion therefrom, applicable to the issue before them — if the Court would have refused a new trial, under such circumstances, it ought not to take the case from the consideration of the jury, upon the ground that no sufficient evidence had been introduced.” Certainly if the question is one of doubt, the Court should not hesitate to refer the facts to the jury.

The danger and difficulty in deciding upon the sufficiency of evidence as a matter of law, is that the province of the jury may be invaded, and the rights of litigants unjustly affected. The tendency of all bodies now-a-days, it seems to me, is too much in the direction of the extension of their own powers; however conservative theirfinclinations ; and this Court as the high and judicial resort in the State, should be careful, as I am sure it is, to guard against encroachment upon the province and rights of others. Although the question now involved has been repeatedly discussed, and much perplexity in the abstract, has been the result; yet it will be found, by reference to all the cases, that rarely has the prerogative of the Court been exercised; and according to my judgment this case 618 cannot and ought not to be distinguished, as one where the evidence for the caveators is so trivial, that no sane mind could for a moment entertain a doubt upon the subject, and therefore withdrawn from the consideration of the jury.