Maryland case law › University System of Maryland v. Mooney

University System of Maryland v. Mooney

407 Md. 390 (2009) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: OtherMurphy, J. (dissenting)✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arises from a contract dispute between the University System of Maryland (Petitioner) and Chesapeake Electrical Systems, Inc. (Chesapeake). Chesapeake performed work for Petitioner but was not paid $43,005.00. Chesapeake assigned its claim to Respondents (Mooney and others), who filed suit in the Circuit Court for Prince George's County on June 4, 2004. The Circuit Court dismissed the complaint, but the Court of Special Appeals reversed and remanded. On remand, the Circuit Court dismissed again, and the Court of Special Appeals again reversed. The Court of Appeals granted certiorari. The majority held that the Respondents were required to exhaust administrative remedies before the Board of Contract Appeals because they were 'persons' under Section 15-217 of the State Finance and Procurement Article, representing the interests of the contracting party. The dissent, by Judge Murp
Questions presented
  • Whether Respondents were required to exhaust administrative remedies before the Board of Contract Appeals under Section 15-217 of the State Finance and Procurement Article.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Dissenting Opinion by MURPHY, J. The complaint that is to be dismissed on the basis of the majority opinion was filed on June 4, 2004. Petitioner never 414 argued to the Circuit Court that the complaint should be dismissed on the ground that the respondents had failed to “exhaust” their administrative remedies. Petitioner never presented this argument in the briefs it filed on the two occasions when the case at bar was pending in the Court of Special Appeals. Petitioner’s “exhaustion” argument was presented for the first time at the second oral argument in the Court of Special Appeals.

Mooney v. University System, 178 Md.App. 637 , 647 n. 2, 943 A.2d 108 (2008). While this issue may be raised for the first time in this Court, I am persuaded that Respondents’ complaint should not be dismissed. If Petitioner had disputed Chesapeake’s right to receive payment, and Chesapeake assigned its unpaid $43,005.00 claim to Respondents, Respondents would have been required to proceed administratively before the Board of Contract Appeals. The case at bar, however, does not involve a dispute between Petitioner and Chesapeake.

While I agree with the majority that “[a] ‘person’ in Section 15-217 of the State Finance and Procurement Article ... does not include only the person awarded the procurement contract, but third parties representing the interests of the contracting party[,]” I do not agree that Respondents should be included in the definition of “person” on the ground that they are involved in the process of “collecting property due to another[.]” Because Respondents are not “representing the interests of the contracting party,” and are not attempting to collect funds that Petitioner had withheld from Chesapeake, I would affirm the judgment of the Court of Special Appeals and order that this case be returned to the Circuit Court for further proceedings not inconsistent with the March 3, 2008 opinion of the Court of Special Appeals.