Maryland case law › Walker v. State

Walker v. State

242 Md. 715 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted of larceny under a burglary indictment after an electrical appliance store in Baltimore City was broken into and six portable televisions, two radios, and a tape recorder were stolen. The appellant approached a stall attendant at the Lexington Market and asked if he could 'get a sale' for a television, which was later identified as one of the stolen items. The stall attendant took possession of the television, sold it to a fellow employee, and gave all the proceeds to the appellant. The appellant's primary contention on appeal was that his larceny conviction was not warranted because the stall attendant was an accomplice and, aside from the attendant's testimony, there was insufficient evidence to support the finding that the appellant had stolen the television. The Court of Appeals disagreed, holding that for a person to be an accomplice, it must be shown tha
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant's conviction of larceny was warranted when the stall attendant was an accomplice and, other than his testimony, there was insufficient evidence to support the finding that the appellant had stolen the television.
  • Whether trial counsel was incompetent, as raised in the brief on instructions from the appellant but not raised below.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. That an electrical appliance store in Baltimore City had been broken into and six portable televisions, two radios and a tape recorder were removed therefrom, that the appellant had approached a stall attendant at the Lexington Market and asked him if he could “get a sale” for a television (subsequently identified as one of those that had been stolen), and that the stall attendant had taken possession of the television and sold it to a fellow employee and gave all of the money received therefor 716 to the appellant are facts which are neither disputed nor denied. The primary contention of the appellant (who was convicted of larceny but was found not guilty of the other charges, including receiving stolen goods, under a burglary indictment) is that his conviction of larceny was not warranted because the stall attendant was an accomplice and, other than his testimony, there was insufficient evidence to support the finding that he (the appellant) had stolen the television. We think otherwise.

The settled law in this State is that for a person to be an accomplice it must be shown that he knowingly, voluntarily and with common interest with the defendant, participated in the crime either as a principal or as an accessory before the fact. Fabian v. State, 235 Md. 306 ; Lucchesi v. State, 232 Md. 465 . There was no such showing. Although the stall attendant (who-had not been indicted) admitted that he had physically received the stolen television from the thief, he denied knowing that it was stolen and that he had participated in any of the offenses with which the appellant was charged.

Moreover, there was no evidence that he had participated in the theft as a principal or that he had instigated or encouraged the commission of the larceny. The only other contention—included in the brief on instructions from the appellant but not raised below—that trial counsel was incompetent, is not supported by the record. On the contrary, the record indicates that counsel actively participated in the defense of the accused at every stage of the proceeding. Certainly, what counsel is now charged with having done or left undone did not make the representation so inadequate as-to deprive the accused of his constitutional rights.

Judgment affirmed.