Maryland case law › Wallace, Johnson & Muir v. Forrest & Stoddert, Garnishees of Benjamin Eyre

Wallace, Johnson & Muir v. Forrest & Stoddert, Garnishees of Benjamin Eyre

2 Md. 261 (1789) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involved competing attachments against the same garnishees, Forrest & Stoddert, who held property of the debtor Benjamin Eyre. Wallace, Johnson & Muir, and William Pennock and others, obtained attachments that were issued earlier in time, but Richard Smith's attachment, though issued last, was first delivered to the sheriff and laid in the hands of the garnishees. The General Court held that Smith had priority of right because his attachment was first delivered to the sheriff and served on the garnishees, notwithstanding that it was issued after the others. The court entered judgments of nonsuit against Wallace, Johnson & Muir, and against William Pennock and others, and entered a judgment of condemnation in favor of Richard Smith for 5,309£ 2s. 4d. current money, plus costs. The court also held that Smith was not required to give security to the defendants upon the judgment of
Questions presented
  • Whether priority of right among competing attachments is determined by the order in which the attachments were issued or by the order in which they were delivered to the sheriff and laid in the hands of the garnishees?
  • Whether the plaintiff, Richard Smith, was required to give security to the defendants upon the judgment of condemnation under the Act of 1715, c. 40, s. 3, when a year and a day had elapsed since the granting of the attachment?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court were of opinion, that Richard Smith had priority of right, his attachment, though issued last, having been first delivered to the sheriff, and laid in the hands of the garnishees. That judgments of nonsuit be entered in the cases wherein Wallace, Johnson, and Muir, are plaintiffs, and wherein William Pennock and others, are plaintiffs. But in the case wherein Richard Smith is plaintiff, that judgment of condemnation be entered for 5,309/. 2$. 4d. current money, and costs,, 266 The Court were also of opinion, that it was not necessary for Smith the plaintiff, to give security to the defendants upon the judgment of condemnation, required by the act of 1715, c. 40. s. 3. a year and a day having elapsed and expired, since the granting of the attachment, On appeal, the Court of Appeals, at June ternij 1792, affirmed the judgment of the General Court,