Maryland case law › Weaver v. State

Weaver v. State

9 Md. App. 637 (1970) · Maryland Court of Special Appeals
Maryland Court of Special AppealsDisposition: ReversedMorton, J.✓ Good law
SummaryIn a non-jury trial, the appellant was convicted of daytime housebreaking and sentenced to three years imprisonment. The State's case rested primarily on the testimony of an accomplice who testified that he and the appellant broke into a residence, removed a television set, and placed it in a truck. The victim testified that she left home at 2:30 p.m. and returned at 5:30 p.m. to find her back door broken and the television missing. A fourteen-year-old neighbor testified that after school she saw some boys with a truck and a television, recognized one as 'Mike' but did not know his last name, could not remember how many other boys were present, and did not identify the appellant as one of the boys. On appeal, the appellant contended that the corroborative evidence of the accomplice's testimony was legally insufficient to support the conviction. The Court of Special Appeals agreed. The co
Questions presented
  • Whether the corroborative evidence of an accomplice's testimony was legally insufficient to support the conviction.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Morton, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Appellant was convicted of daytime housebreaking in a non-jury trial and sentenced to three years imprisonment. In this appeal he contends that the corroborative evidence of an accomplice’s testimony was legally insufficient to support the conviction. We agree.

The accomplice testified that he and the appellant broke into a residence, removed a television set therefrom and placed it in a truck. The owner of the television set testified that she left home at 2:30 p.m. and when she returned at 5:30 p.m. the same day, she found the back door of her residence broken and the television set missing. A fourteen year old girl who was a neighbor of the victim testified that after she came home from school on the day of the breaking, she “saw some boys with a truck, and they had a television with them * * She “recognized one of the boys as Mike” but did not know his last name and could not remember how many other boys were 639 present. She did not identify appellant as having been one of the boys she saw with the television.

The testimony of an accomplice, alone, will not support a conviction unless it is corroborated by evidence “tending to show that the accused was either identified with the perpetrators of the crime or participated in the commission of the crime itself.” Gaskins v. State, 7 Md. App. 99, 103 . While the testimony of an accomplice needs only slight corroboration, we feel, under the circumstances here, that the corroboration was legally insufficient to support the conviction. Other than the testimony of the accomplice, there was no evidence presented from which the criminal agency of the appellant could be inferred. Judgment reversed.

Case remanded for a new trial ;provided state forthwith satisfies trial court additional evidence is available.