Maryland case law › Wells v. Thomas

Wells v. Thomas

72 Md. 26 (1890) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedStone, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a tax sale of real estate conducted by the treasurer of Anne Arundel County under the Act of 1884, ch. 462, a special law applicable only to that county. The Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County fixed the legal charges and expenses attending the sale, and the appellant sought review of that order in the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals, speaking through Judge Stone, held that it lacked appellate jurisdiction. The Act of 1884, ch. 462, grants no right of appeal to the Court of Appeals, and in the absence of such statutory authorization, no appeal lies. The Court further held that the question of the propriety of the legal expenses fixed by the Circuit Court could not be brought before it indirectly by way of mandamus, because the action of the Circuit Court on that question is final. The Court rejected the notion that it could review the matter merely because
Questions presented
  • Whether the Court of Appeals has jurisdiction to review the action of the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County in deciding what are the proper legal charges and expenses attending a sale of real estate made by the authority of the treasurer of Anne Arundel County under the Act of 1884, ch. 462.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stone, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The only object of this ajipeal seems to be to get this Court to review the action of the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, in deciding what are the proper legal charges and expenses attending a sale of real estate made by the authority of the treasurer of Anne Arundel County under the Act of 1884, ch. 462. This can not be done. The Act of 1884, ch. 462, is a special law applying to Anne Arundel County only.

No appeal is given by that Act to this Court, and none therefore exists. No appeal would lie directly from this order of the Circuit Court fixing the legal expenses attending a tax sale in Anne Arundel, nor can that question be 28 indirectly brought before us upon a mandamus. The action of the Circuit Court is final upon that question. Meyer vs. Steuart, et al., 48 Md., 423 ; Margraff vs. Cunningham’s Heirs, 57 Md., 585 , and many other cases.

(Decided 5th February, 1890.) This Court may have, in some cases, in deference to the wishes of both parties, expressed an opinion upon questions that were not before this Court as a matter of right. But the practice is not to be commended. If the Legislature had intended us to review the action of the Circuit Court in cases like, the present, it would doubtless have made such provision in the Act. In default of such provision, we must leave the question where it seems to us the Legislature intended it to be left, in the hands of the Circuit Court.

Aj^eal dismissed.