Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedMcSherry, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to Western Md. R. R. Co. v. State, use of Shirk, ante p. 637, and presents the identical legal questions. Landis and Shirk were both riding in the same caboose and both jumped from the train while it was in motion; Shirk was killed, Landis was injured. The same instructions were given and the same modifications to the defendant's prayers were made in both cases. The Court of Appeals, per McSherry, C.J., held that because there was error in the rulings in Shirk's case, the same errors are present here. The judgment in favor of the plaintiff (Landis) is therefore reversed and a new trial awarded. The opinion does not independently recite the facts or reasoning but incorporates by reference the prior decision in Shirk. No new legal rule is announced; the disposition rests entirely on the doctrine of stare decisis or consistency with the companion case. The Court doe
Questions presented
Whether the trial court erred in its instructions and in modifying the defendant's prayers, as in the companion case of Western Md. R. R. Co. v. State, use of Shirk.
Opinion by McSherry, C. J., The only particular in which this case differs from the preceding one, Western Md. R. R. Co. v. State, use of Shirk, ante p. 637, is this, that Landis was hurt whilst Shirk was killed. They were both riding in the same cabosse and both jumped therefrom whilst the train was in motion. Precisely the same instructions were given in both cases and identically the same modifications were made to the defendant’s prayers in this case that were made in the other. This being so the same questions are presented which arose in Shirk’s case and were there considered and decided.
As there was error in the rulings in Shirk’s case so the same errors are found in this and for the reasons given in that case the judgment in favor of the plaintiff here must be reversed and a new trial will be awarded.