Maryland case law › Whitaker v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction
Whitaker v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryWhitaker was convicted on June 12, 1956, of robbery with a deadly weapon in the Criminal Court of Baltimore and sentenced to 10 years' confinement in the House of Correction. He was represented by counsel at his original trial and at the hearing below. In this collateral proceeding, Whitaker raised what he termed 'constitutional violations,' but his only contentions merely challenged the sufficiency of the evidence at his original trial. The Court of Appeals of Maryland, sitting per curiam, held that the sufficiency of the evidence adduced at trial cannot be reviewed in collateral proceedings. The court relied on its prior decision in Johnson v. Warden, 214 Md. 608, noting that it had 'repeatedly held' this principle. Because Whitaker's claims were purely evidentiary challenges that could only have been raised on direct appeal, they were not cognizable in a post-conviction or habeas corp
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the sufficiency of the evidence adduced at the trial of a defendant can be reviewed in collateral proceedings.
Per Curiam. Whitaker was convicted, on June 12, 1956, of robbery with a deadly weapon in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, and sentenced to 10 years’ confinement in the House of Correction. He was represented by counsel at his original trial as well as the hearing herein below. His only contentions, which he terms “constitutional violations”, merely challenge the sufficiency of the evidence at his original trial.
We have repeatedly held that the sufficiency of the evidence adduced at the trial of a defendant cannot be reviewed in collateral proceedings. Johnson v. Warden, 214 Md. 608 . Application denied.