Maryland case law › Whitley v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Whitley v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

214 Md. 647 (1957) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHammond✓ Good law
SummaryJoseph Olief Whitley sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Raine of the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. Whitley was serving a twelve-year sentence in the House of Correction for murder in the second degree. He alleged three grounds for relief: (1) that his court-appointed counsel was generally incompetent and specifically ineffective for failing to put him on the stand to testify in his own behalf and for failing to introduce evidence that would have changed the complexion of the State's case; (2) that one of the State's witnesses committed perjury; and (3) that unfavorable publicity caused prejudice against him. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion delivered by Judge Hammond, denied the application. On the ineffective assistance claim, the Court held that habeas corpus is inappropriate where the applicant does not allege bad faith, fraud
Questions presented
  • Whether habeas corpus relief is available where the applicant alleges that his court-appointed counsel was incompetent for failing to put him on the stand and for failing to introduce evidence, but does not allege bad faith, fraud, or collusion by his attorney with any State official, nor that he complained to the court concerning his counsel or requested the right to take the stand?
  • Whether the mere allegation that a State's witness committed perjury, absent facts establishing knowing participation by State officials in the use of perjured testimony, is sufficient to justify the issuance of a writ of habeas corpus?
  • Whether unfavorable publicity causing prejudice against the applicant can serve as a ground for habeas corpus, even though it could have been raised on appeal?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Hammond, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Joseph Olief Whitley seeks leave to appeal from a denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Raine of the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, by which writ he sought to ob 649 tain release from a sentence of twelve years in the House of Correction for murder in the second degree. Applicant alleges that his counsel was generally incompetent and specifically so in not putting him on the stand to testify in his own behalf, and in failing to introduce evidence which would have changed the complexion of the State’s case. He does not, however, allege bad faith, fraud, or collusion by his attorney with any State official, nor does he allege that he complained to the court concerning his court-appointed counsel or requested the right to take the stand.

Habeas corpus is inappropriate under the circumstances and cannot be made to serve the purpose of an appeal or a new trial on the question of innocence or guilt. Sykes v. Warden, 201 Md. 662, 663 ; Barker v. Warden, 208 Md. 662, 667 ; Buffington v. Warden, 201 Md. 642 . Applicant further alleges that one of the State’s witnesses committed perjury. We have held repeatedly that in the absence of facts establishing the knowing participation by State officials in the use of perjured testimony, the mere allegation that it was used is insufficient to justify the issuance of the writ.

Ramberg v. Warden, 209 Md. 631, 633 . The final allegation is that unfavorable publicity caused prejudice against him. Although this could have been raised on appeal, it cannot serve as a ground for habeas corpus. Randall v. Warden, 208 Md. 667, 671 .

Application denied, with costs.