Maryland case law › Williams v. State

Williams v. State

228 Md. 356 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant was convicted of robbery in the Criminal Court of Baltimore and appealed, contending that the State's evidence was so conflicting and incredible that it was legally insufficient to sustain the conviction. The victim testified that he was assaulted from behind, knocked down, and robbed of $40 by two persons whom he did not see. An eyewitness, Charlotte Roberts, testified that she knew the appellant, saw him strike the victim, cross the street, and tell an unidentified person to 'go get his money'; when that person could not lift the victim alone, the appellant returned, helped, and rifled the victim's pockets. Another eyewitness for the defense, Ethel Cox, testified that the appellant knocked the victim down and everyone 'took off,' and that a different person (whom she knew) later helped the victim to his feet alone; she gave no testimony as to who robbed the victim. The Co
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence produced by the State was in such conflict as to make it so incredible that its legal sufficiency to sustain the conviction of the appellant for robbery is questionable.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. This appeal is based on the premise that the evidence produced by the State was in such conflict as to make it so incredible that its legal sufficiency to sustain the conviction of the appellant for robbery is questionable. But, as we read the record, such is not the case. The victim was assaulted, knocked down and robbed of $40 on a street in Baltimore.

He testified that he had been assaulted and robbed by two persons who had come upon him “from behind,” and for that reason had not seen his assailants. There was, however, other testimony by an eyewitness (Charlotte Roberts) who testified that the appellant (whom she knew) had struck the victim and had then crossed the street and told another person (whom she could not identify) to “go get his money,” but when the unidentified person could not lift the victim by himself, the appellant returned to help and at that time rifled the pockets of the victim. On behalf of the appellant, there was testimony by another eyewitness (Ethel Cox) to the effect that the appellant had come across the street and knocked the victim down, whereupon everyone “took off,” and that after the assault another person (whom she knew) approached the victim and alone helped him to his 358 feet, but she gave no testimony as to who robbed the victim. Clearly the testimony of the witness Roberts, as to what she saw, and the testimony of the victim, as to what was taken from him, was, if believed, sufficient to sustain the conviction.

The credibility of the witnesses was a matter to be considered by the trier of the facts. Mason v. State, 225 Md. 74; Bush v. State, 223 Md. 382 . Judgment affirmed.