Maryland case law › Wisner v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Wisner v. Director of Patuxent Institution

230 Md. 608 (1962) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryAdam Wisner sought leave to appeal from an order of the Criminal Court of Baltimore recommitting him to Patuxent Institution as a defective delinquent, entered April 6, 1962, on a jury finding in redetermination proceedings. He had first been found a defective delinquent by a jury in November 1959, following a November 1958 commitment to Patuxent for examination and report. That initial commitment followed his conviction on a guilty plea to larceny of goods valued at $100 or more (a television set worth $129.95), for which he received a two-year sentence. Wisner raised four grounds for leave to appeal. First, he contended the Defective Delinquent Law did not apply to him because he had not been convicted of two crimes committed in Maryland on or after June 1, 1954. The Court of Appeals rejected this, holding that the 1958 offense for which he was convicted and sentenced was committed in
Questions presented
  • Whether the Defective Delinquent Law was applicable to the applicant where he had not been convicted of two crimes committed in this State on or after June 1, 1954.
  • Whether the applicant received a fair trial in the redetermination proceedings.
  • Whether the applicant's counsel properly represented him.
  • Whether Dr. Boslow, the Director of Patuxent, committed perjury against the applicant by using trickery.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The applicant, Adam Wisner, seeks leave to appeal from an order of the Criminal Court of Baltimore, dated April 6, 1962, recommitting him to Patuxent Institution, which was entered in accordance with the finding of a jury, in proceedings to redetermine the question of Wisner’s defective delinquency, that he was a defective delinquent. He had first been found to be such by another jury in November, 1959, following his commitment to Patuxent for examination and report in November, 1958. This first commitment (for examination) had been upon his conviction on a plea of guilty to a charge of larceny of goods of a value of $100.00 or more (a television set valued at $129.95), for which offense he was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment.

The applicant asserts four grounds upon which he seeks leave to appeal. One of them is, in substance, that the Defective Delinquent Law was not applicable to him because he had not been convicted of two crimes committed in this State on or after June 1, 1954. This contention is untenable. The offense for which he was convicted and sentenced was committed in this State in 1958 and was (and is) a felony under Code (1957), Art. 27, sec. 340.

That alone was (and is) a sufficient basis for invoking the Defective Delinquent Law. See Code (1957), Art. 31B, secs. 6 (a) and 16 (as in force in 1958 and 1959), and Code (1962 Cum. Supp.), Art. 31B, sec. 6 (a), embodying 610 the amendments of sec. 6 (a) made by Ch. 629 of the Acts of 1961. The applicant’s other contentions are: (a) that he did not receive a fair trial in the redetermination proceedings; (b) that his counsel did not properly represent him; and (c) that Dr. Boslow, the Director of Patuxent, “committed perjury against * * * [him] by using trickery.” No facts are alleged in support of any of these three claims.

If the second and third are intended to support the first, they in themselves are devoid of any showing of facts to support the conclusions therein asserted. These bald allegations are not sufficient to show that leave to appeal should be granted. See Perkerson v. Director of Patuxent Institution, 226 Md. 666 , 174 A. 2d 436 ; Maryland Rule 894 a 2 (a) (requiring “a concise statement of the reasons why the order should be reversed or modified, and * * * a list of the errors allegedly committed by the lower court.”); and specifically as to the insufficiency of the allegations charging perjury, see Whitley v. Warden, 222 Md. 608, 158 A. 2d 905 , cert. den. 364 U. S. 808 ; Washington v. Warden, 225 Md. 623 , 169 A. 2d 419 (both Post Conviction Procedure Act cases); and Meredith v. Director of Patuxent Institution, 226 Md. 653 , 172 A. 2d 501 (a Defective Delinquent case). Application denied.