Maryland case law › Worthington v. Bullitt

Worthington v. Bullitt

6 Md. 172 (1854) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedEccleston, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a bill filed by creditors of Samuel Worthington, Sr., seeking to set aside certain conveyances as fraudulent. The complainants alleged that deeds executed by the elder Worthington in 1825 and a deed of September 8, 1826, from Walter to Samuel Worthington, Jr., were made to hinder, delay, and defraud creditors. Samuel Worthington, Jr., claimed title to the property under an alleged parol contract or agreement of 1817, and relied upon acts of part performance to take the case out of the statute of frauds and to defeat the creditors' claims. The chancellor decreed in favor of the complainants as to the deeds of 1825 and dismissed the bill as to the deed of 1826. Judge Eccleston, delivering a separate concurring opinion, addressed two evidentiary and equitable issues. First, he stated that the conveyance bond mentioned in the proceedings was not
Questions presented
  • Whether the proof in regard to the alleged parol contract or agreement of 1817 can be considered as in the cause, notwithstanding the deed of 1825.
  • Whether the acts relied upon as part performance of the alleged parol agreement of 1817 can authorize a court of equity to sustain the claim of Samuel Worthington in opposition to the claims of the complainants as creditors of his father.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Eccleston, J., delivered the following separate opinion, concurring in the affirmance of the decree r The conveyance bond, mentioned in the proceedings, I do not think is properly in evidence- before us. Whether the proof in- regard to the alleged parol contract or agreement of 1817 can be considered as in the cause, notwithstanding the deed of 1825, I deem- it unnecessary to decide, because, admitting it to be before us, nevertheless, under the circumstances disclosed in the record, the acts which are relied' upon as part performance of that agreement, cannot, in my opinion, authorize a court of equity to sustain the claim- of Samuel Worthington in opposition to the claims of the complainants as creditors of his father. I think the decree of the chancellor should be affirmed in regard to the deeds of 1825, and also in reference to that portion of it which directs the bill to be dismissed so far as relates to the deed of the 8th of September 1826, from Walter to Samuel Worthington.