Maryland case law › Wright v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Wright v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

194 Md. 705 (1949) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryWright filed an application for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. He was imprisoned under a two-year sentence imposed by a Montgomery County justice of the peace for assault and battery. Wright alleged that the magistrate denied him his rights to employ counsel or have counsel appointed; that he was brought to trial within forty-eight hours of arrest without a preliminary hearing, thus denying him the right to prepare his defense; that he was arrested before a warrant was issued; and that the testimony did not support the charge in the warrant and commitment because it showed no beating. The Court of Appeals held that habeas corpus is not a proper remedy where appeal is available, and that Wright could have obtained a trial de novo by appeal and made all his contentions there. The Court recognized a narrow exception: exceptional cases where conviction was had i
Questions presented
  • Whether habeas corpus is a proper remedy where the petitioner could have obtained a trial de novo by appeal and could have made all the contentions he now makes.
  • Whether the petitioner's allegations bring his case within the exceptional circumstance where habeas corpus is the only effective means of preserving constitutional rights because conviction was had in disregard of those rights and like disregard prevented appeal.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

706 PER CURIAM. This is an application for leave to appeal from refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. Petitioner is imprisoned under sentence, by a Montgomery County justice of the peace, of two years for assault and battery. He alleges that the magistrate denied him “his rights to employ counsel to represent him in court or that, the court appoint him counsel”; that he “was brought to trial within forty-eight hours from arrest without his rights of a preliminary hearing and was therefore denied the right to prepare his defense properly”; that he was arrested before a warrant was issued, and that the testimony did not support the charge in the warrant and the commitment because it showed no beating.

By appeal petitioner could have obtained a trial de novo and could have made all the contentions he now makes. His case cannot be retried on habeas corpus, and habeas corpus is not a proper remedy where appeal is available. Loughran v. Warden of House of Correction, 192 Md. 719 , 64 A. 2d 712 . It is conceivable 'that even among the relatively minor cases tried before a magistrate, there may be exceptional cases where conviction has been had in disregard of the constitutional rights of the accused and like disregard of his rights may have prevented appeal, and thus the writ of habeas corpus is the only effective means of preserving his rights.

Olewiler v. Brady, 185 Md. 341, 345 , 44 A. 2d 807 . No facts are alleged which remotely suggest any such exceptional case. Application denied, without costs.