Maryland case law › Cheeseboro v. Warden of MaryLand Penitentiary

Cheeseboro v. Warden of MaryLand Penitentiary

224 Md. 660 (1961) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Maryland Court of Appeals denied an application for leave to appeal from the dismissal of a petition for post conviction relief. The petitioner, Cheeseboro, had filed a post conviction petition alleging numerous grounds, including that the trial court received into evidence a 'coerced, false and involuntary' confession. The hearing judge (Sodaro, J.) dismissed the petition, concluding that the petitioner was merely attempting to use a collateral proceeding as a motion for a new trial or an appeal. In his application for leave to appeal, the petitioner renewed only one original contention—that he was convicted on a coerced confession—and raised three new contentions for the first time: (ii) that he had additional evidence precluded from presentation because he was not present at the hearing; (iii) that trial counsel failed to file a motion for a new trial o
Questions presented
  • Whether the involuntary character of a confession may be raised in a post conviction proceeding.
  • Whether contentions raised for the first time in the Court of Appeals on an application for leave to appeal from the dismissal of a post conviction petition are properly before the court.
  • Whether the presence of the petitioner at the post conviction hearing is required.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In his petition for post conviction relief, the petitioner alleged numerous reasons—including one to the effect that the trial court erred when it received into evidence a “coerced, false and involuntary” confession—he claimed entitled him to post conviction relief. None had substance in that all of them concerned matters involving procedural irregularities, incompetency of trial counsel and the weight and sufficiency of the evidence which cannot be raised in a post conviction proceeding. Sodaro, J., who heard the petition, correctly concluded that the petitioner was “merely attempting to have a collateral proceeding serve as a motion for a new trial or as an appeal,” and dismissed the petition.

In this application for leave to appeal, the applicant, in addition to renewing only one of the original contentions, (i) that he was convicted on a “coerced” confession, now contends for the first time (ii) that he has additional evidence to support his original petition which he was precluded from presenting at the hearing because he was not present; (iii) that though he requested trial counsel to file a motion for a new trial or to take an appeal after his conviction, the attorney failed to do so; and (iv) that though he had requested the trial judge (by a letter) before he was sentenced to enter an appeal for him, no appeal was entered. 662 Contentions (ii), (iii) and (iv), which were made for the first time in this Court, even if they had substance, are not properly before us and will not be considered. Chislom v. Warden, 223 Md. 681 , 164 A. 2d 912 (1960). With respect to contention (ii), we repeat what has often been said before that the presence of the petitioner at the post conviction hearing, though discretionary with the court, is not required. Henson v. Warden, 223 Md. 674 , 164 A. 2d 273 (1960).

As to the only question properly before us, the answer is that the involuntary character of a confession may be raised on an appeal, but not in a collateral proceeding. Whitley v. Warden, 222 Md. 608 , 158 A. 2d 905 (1960). Application denied.