Maryland case law › Chislom v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Chislom v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

223 Md. 681 (1960) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Denied⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryPer curiam opinion denying an application for leave to appeal from an order denying post conviction relief from a robbery conviction. The Court addressed several contentions: (1) improper identification at a line-up is an irregularity in a preliminary investigative procedure not reviewable in a collateral proceeding; (2) a co-defendant's statement that petitioner was not one of the robbers raises a question of guilt or innocence for the trier of facts, reviewable only on motion for new trial or direct appeal; (3) failure to furnish an indigent with a trial transcript immediately after trial, where no request was made until after the time for direct appeal expired, has no merit; (4) the claim of denial of jury trial is contrary to the facts because the record shows petitioner, through counsel, elected a court trial, and by failing to seasonably object to that election, he waived the right
Questions presented
  • Whether the claim of improper identification at a line-up of suspects can be reviewed in a collateral proceeding.
  • Whether the contention that a co-defendant had stated that the petitioner was not one of the three robbers is reviewable in a post conviction proceeding.
  • Whether it was error not to furnish an indigent petitioner with a copy of the trial transcript immediately after trial, where he did not request it until after the time for a direct appeal had expired.
  • Whether the petitioner was denied a jury trial.
  • Whether contentions raised for the first time in this Court are properly before the Court.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. This is an application for leave to appeal from the order denying the applicant post conviction relief from his conviction for robbery. All of the contentions raised below were clearly without substance. The claim of the petitioner that he had not been properly identified at the line-up of suspects was an irregularity in a 683 preliminary investigative procedure which cannot be reviewed in a collateral proceeding.

Rice v. Warden, 221 Md. 604 , 156 A. 2d 632 (1959). The contention that a co-defendant had stated that the petitioner was not one of the three robbers would raise a question of guilt or innocence for the trier of facts to determine, but was reviewable only on a motion for a new trial or a direct appeal. Barbee v. Warden, 220 Md. 647 , 151 A. 2d 167 (1959) . Though the petitioner had not requested a copy of the trial transcript until after the time for a direct appeal had expired, he contends—because he was an indigent-—that it was error not to furnish him with a copy immediately after trial.

The contention has no merit. See Brown v. Warden, 221 Md. 582 , 155 A. 2d 648 (1959). The claim that the petitioner had been denied a jury trial is contrary to the facts. The record shows that the petitioner (through his counsel) elected to be tried by the court.

Since he failed to seasonably object to the election made on his behalf, he thereby waived the right to thereafter raise the question. Cf. Galloway v. Warden, 221 Md. 611 , 157 A. 2d 284 (1960). The other contentions raised for the first time in this Court, even if they had substance, are not properly before us, and will not be considered.

Application denied.