Maryland case law › Rice v. Warden

Rice v. Warden

221 Md. 604 (1959) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryPhilip Raymond Rice filed an application for leave to appeal from the denial of post conviction relief by Judge Manley in the Criminal Court of Baltimore on July 16, 1959. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, denied the application. The Court held that the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act is a procedural act and does not enlarge the substantive rights of review. Consequently, the Court ruled that the legality of a search and seizure cannot be raised under the Act, citing Banks v. Warden and Mears v. Warden. The Court further noted that after conviction a question of bail may not be raised on habeas corpus, citing Brooks v. Warden, and that alleged irregularities in preliminary proceedings or procedures which may not be raised on habeas corpus likewise cannot be reviewed under the Post Conviction Procedure Act. The Court relied on State v. D'Onofrio for the principle that
Questions presented
  • Whether the legality of a search and seizure can be raised under the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act.
  • Whether a question of bail may be raised after conviction on habeas corpus or under the Post Conviction Procedure Act.
  • Whether alleged irregularities in preliminary proceedings or procedures which may not be raised on habeas corpus may be reviewed under the Post Conviction Procedure Act.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

221 Md. 604 (1959) 156 A.2d 632 RICE v. WARDEN OF MARYLAND PENITENTIARY [P.C. No. 48, September Term, 1959.] Court of Appeals of Maryland. Decided December 21, 1959. Before BRUNE, C.J., and HENDERSON, HAMMOND, PRESCOTT and HORNEY, JJ. 605 PER CURIAM: The Post Conviction Procedure Act is a procedural act and not an enlargement of substantive rights of review. State v. D'Onofrio, 221 Md. 20 , 155 A.2d 643 .

The question of the legality of search and seizure cannot be raised under the Act. Banks v. Warden, 220 Md. 652 , 151 A.2d 897 ; Mears v. Warden, 220 Md. 682 , 155 A.2d 72 . After conviction a question of bail may not be raised on habeas corpus, Brooks v. Warden, 218 Md. 650 , 145 A.2d 569 ; nor may alleged irregularities in preliminary proceedings or procedures which may not be raised on habeas corpus be reviewed under the Post Conviction Procedure Act. For the above reasons, and for the reasons stated in the opinion and order of Judge Manley filed in this case in the Criminal Court of Baltimore on July 16, 1959, the application of Philip Raymond Rice for leave to appeal is denied.

Application for leave to appeal denied.